Allegations of Misconduct

The detection of scientific misconduct typically arises from reports by co-authors, collaborators, peer reviewers, editors, or readers. Increasingly, misconduct is identified through post-publication analyses and replication studies conducted by independent experts.

When an allegation of scientific misconduct—such as fabrication, falsification, or plagiarism—is raised regarding a manuscript under consideration or already published, the journal editor is responsible for initiating a prompt, thorough, and confidential preliminary assessment. However, the editor does not conduct formal investigations and will defer such matters to the relevant institutions.

Our editorial approach adheres strictly to guidelines from the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), World Association of Medical Editors (WAME), Council of Science Editors (CSE), and the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). We utilize COPE flowcharts and retraction guidelines, as well as CSE resources.

Upon receiving an allegation, the editor will:

1. Conduct an initial confidential assessment and may request supporting documentation from the complainant.

2. If the allegation appears credible, contact the corresponding author to request an explanation.

3. Evaluate the author’s response:

  • If misconduct is supported by evidence, the journal may take appropriate editorial actions, including correction, expression of concern, or retraction, and may notify the author’s institution.

  • If the author's explanation adequately resolves the concern, no further action will be taken.

  • If the explanation is unsatisfactory, incomplete, or absent, the matter will be referred to the relevant institutional authorities for formal investigation.

The formal investigation of alleged misconduct is the responsibility of the author’s institution, funding agency, or relevant authority. The journal may request updates regarding the investigation process where appropriate.

Editors must maintain strict confidentiality throughout this process and will communicate allegations discreetly to avoid unintended disclosure.

If necessary, editors may confidentially consult with editors of other journals to coordinate responses.

This policy ensures integrity, fairness, and transparency in addressing allegations, thereby safeguarding the credibility of the journal and the scientific record.